Jun 25, 2024

How do you measure Gen AI Deployment & Pilot success: Key Performance Indicators and Metrics

Measuring the performance of Gen AI experiment & pilots is crucial for a) verifying their effectiveness b) refine subsequent iterations of the project c) assessing impact & value delivered

Here's the KPI's for Gen AI implementation, that can help Decision-makers & Stakeholders to measure success of the AI Projects & Pilot journey

Measuring the performance of your gen AI experiments and pilots is crucial for a) verifying their effectiveness and b) refine subsequent iterations of the project c) assessing the impact and value they deliver to the organisation goals.

MIT Sloan Management Review and Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Report (2017): This report, titled "Artificial Intelligence and the New Era of Productivity," found that companies with well-defined KPIs for AI initiatives were 1.5 times more likely to report exceeding their business goals.

Without clear metrics, it's difficult to determine if your AI is actually working. KPIs provide quantifiable measures to evaluate the effectiveness of your AI in achieving its intended goals. In terms of Alignment with Business Objectives, to bring data-driven adjustments and improvements to your AI model, quantify the return on investment (ROI). Business landscape is constantly evolving, KPIs insights refine your AI strategy and ensure it remains relevant over time. Stakeholders can understand the value proposition of AI clear and concisely.

By setting the right KPIs, tracking them diligently, and using the insights to make adjustments, organizations can maximize and optimize the potential of AI and generative AI technologies for better results.

Here are some key questions to consider:

The purpose of the Gen AI deployment: What do you want the Gen AI to achieve?
Are you aiming to improve customer satisfaction or automate tasks?

The target audience: Who will be using the Gen AI powered chatbot? (Support Agents, Marketing team, End Customers, etc.)

The budget: How much are you willing to spend on the AI execution?

End user’s expectation: what are their experience preferences for a Gen AI tech?

The available resources: Do you have the resources to develop and maintain the Gen AI chatbot?

Enough data: do you have enough data to tailor Gen AI/LLM model?

Quantitative and Qualitative success

Evaluating the effectiveness of generative AI in requires a blend of quantitative and qualitative metrics. Here's a breakdown of key areas to consider:

A study published in the Journal of Information Technology Research found that companies focusing on measuring the business value of AI projects achieved a 3x higher return on investment (ROI) compared to those without a clear measurement strategy.

Quantitative Metrics:

  • Resolution Rates: Track the percentage of issues resolved by the generative AI without needing human intervention. This reflects the AI's ability to handle customer inquiries effectively.
  • Self-Service Adoption: Monitor how often customers (for external facing support) or employees (for internal facing assisatnce) utilize the generative AI. High adoption rates suggest the AI is user-friendly and fulfills customer needs.
  • Average Resolution Time: Measure the time it takes for the AI to resolve an issue. Faster resolution times indicate efficiency and a positive customer experience.
  • First Contact Resolution (FCR): Track the percentage of issues addressed during the initial interaction with the AI. High FCR indicates the AI's competency in handling inquiries without escalation.
  • Customer Satisfaction Surveys: Embed surveys after interactions with the AI to gauge customer sentiment. Tools like Net Promoter Score (NPS) can measure customer loyalty and satisfaction with the AI's support.

Qualitative Metrics:

  • Effort Score: Surveys can assess the level of effort required from end user to resolve their issues using the AI. Lower effort scores indicate a smooth and efficient experience.
  • User Feedback Analysis: Analyze qualitative feedback from customer user and conversations to identify areas for improvement in the AI's responses and functionalities.
  • Human Agent Efficiency: Measure how generative AI impacts employee workload. If the AI effectively resolves simpler issues, it frees up employees for more complex inquiries.
  • Cost Savings: Evaluate if generative AI reduces costs associated with traditional workflows, by automating mundane tasks.
  • Agent Productivity: Measure the time saved by employees due to the AI deflecting routine inquiries. This can free them up for complex issues improving efficiency.

Additional Considerations:

  • Natural Language Processing (NLP) Performance: Evaluate how well the AI understands and responds to natural language queries. This ensures a seamless and intuitive user experience.
  • Human-in-the-Loop: Assess the effectiveness of integrating humans with the AI for more complex issues. A seamless handoff process is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction.
  • Fine-tuning Requirements: Measure the amount of effort needed to train the LLM model and maintain the AI for optimal performance. According to McKinsey research, establishing KPIs allows organizations to prioritize data collection efforts, ensuring they gather the information most critical for AI success.
Business Value Improvement Metrics / KPI's for Generative AI by Use Cases

Measuring the success of early Generative AI programs and pilots

Evaluating the success of early generative AI programs and pilots requires a nuanced approach. Here's a framework that blends quantitative and qualitative measures:

Early-stage Considerations:

Focus on Learning: Early generative AI programs are often about exploration and learning. Embrace experimentation and prioritize gathering insights over achieving perfect results.

Data Collection: Set up mechanisms to capture data on user interactions and AI performance during the pilot. This data will be invaluable for refining the model in future iterations.

Iterative Improvement: Don't expect a perfect solution right away. Use the learnings from the pilot to iterate on the AI and gradually improve its capabilities.

Incremental vs. Exponential Pilots: Early programs can be designed to test specific functionalities (incremental) or explore broader business model opportunities (exponential). Choose the approach that aligns with your goals.

Incremental Pilots, KPI metric:

Accuracy and Reliability: How well does the generated output match the desired format. This could involve measuring the factual correctness of creative text formats, the coherence of generated code, or the effectiveness of automated responses in interactions.

Completion Time: Measure the time it takes for the AI to generate the desired output. Faster generation is generally better, but prioritize quality over speed for complex tasks. This identifies areas for improvement in the AI's capabilities.

Time Efficiency: Measure the time saved by using the generative AI compared to the traditional method. This is crucial for repetitive tasks the AI automates.

User Satisfaction: Gather feedback through to understand user perception of the AI's usefulness and ease of use with the specific functionality being tested for any task.

Exponential Pilots, KPI metric:

User Adoption: Monitor how many users interact & how often a user interact with the generative AI, how many queries Gen AI able to solve, within the pilot program

Engagement Metrics: Analyze session length, user input complexity, and the number of tasks attempted using the AI. This gauges user engagement and the range of use cases explored.

Cost Savings Potential: Estimate the potential cost reductions achievable if the AI were fully implemented across relevant business areas. While cost might not be the primary goal, this helps assess potential return on investment (ROI).

Alignment with Business Goals: Evaluate how the pilot impacts broader business objectives. Did it uncover new opportunities? Did it validate the potential of generative AI to solve a critical business challenge? A Deloitte report highlights that clear KPIs create a common language around AI success, fostering collaboration between technical teams and business stakeholders.

Incremental vs. Exponential Pilots KPI metric

To Wrap up

Make sure your KPIs are SMART - Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound.

The KPIs for a pilot program will differ from those for a fully deployed generative AI solution. For early pilots, focus on core functionalities and user engagement. Later, track business impact and ROI.

Don't rely solely on hard numbers. User feedback, surveys, and focus groups can provide valuable insights into user experience and satisfaction with the generative AI.

Gradually move beyond basic functionality metrics. Track how generative AI creates value for your organization. This could be cost savings, improved efficiency, increased revenue, or enhanced customer satisfaction.

Balance Leading and Lagging Indicators. Leading indicators that reflect the effectiveness of your GenAI implementation (e.g., AI-powered self-service resolution rate in customer support). Additionally, monitor Lagging indicators that measure the ultimate business impact (e.g., customer satisfaction score).

Decision pointsOpen-Source LLMClose-Source LLM
AccessibilityThe code behind the LLM is freely available for anyone to inspect, modify, and use. This fosters collaboration and innovation.The underlying code is proprietary and not accessible to the public. Users rely on the terms and conditions set by the developer.
CustomizationLLMs can be customized and adapted for specific tasks or applications. Developers can fine-tune the models and experiment with new techniques.Customization options are typically limited. Users might have some options to adjust parameters, but are restricted to the functionalities provided by the developer.
Community & DevelopmentBenefit from a thriving community of developers and researchers who contribute to improvements, bug fixes, and feature enhancements.Development is controlled by the owning company, with limited external contributions.
SupportSupport may come from the community, but users may need to rely on in-house expertise for troubleshooting and maintenance.Typically comes with dedicated support from the developer, offering professional assistance and guidance.
CostGenerally free to use, with minimal costs for running the model on your own infrastructure, & may require investment in technical expertise for customization and maintenance.May involve licensing fees, pay-per-use models or require cloud-based access with associated costs.
Transparency & BiasGreater transparency as the training data and methods are open to scrutiny, potentially reducing bias.Limited transparency makes it harder to identify and address potential biases within the model.
IPCode and potentially training data are publicly accessible, can be used as a foundation for building new models.Code and training data are considered trade secrets, no external contributions
SecurityTraining data might be accessible, raising privacy concerns if it contains sensitive information & Security relies on the communityThe codebase is not publicly accessible, control over the training data and stricter privacy measures & Security depends on the vendor's commitment
ScalabilityUsers might need to invest in their own infrastructure to train and run very large models & require leveraging community experts resourcesCompanies often have access to significant resources for training and scaling their models and can be offered as cloud-based services
Deployment & Integration ComplexityOffers greater flexibility for customization and integration into specific workflows but often requires more technical knowledgeTypically designed for ease of deployment and integration with minimal technical setup. Customization options might be limited to functionalities offered by the vendor.
10 ponits you need to evaluate for your Enterprise Usecases

At Fluid AI, we stand at the forefront of this AI revolution, helping organizations kickstart their AI journey. If you’re seeking a solution for your organization, look no further. We’re committed to making your organization future-ready, just like we’ve done for many others.
Take the first step towards this exciting journey by booking a free demo call with us today. Let’s explore the possibilities together, unlocking the full potential of AI for your organization and starting with your Pilot or Production journey. Remember, the future belongs to those who prepare for it today.

Didn't find specific use-case you're looking for?

Talk to our Gen AI Expert !

Book your free 1-1 strategic call

- Outline your AI strategic roadmap and identify high-impact use cases.
- Craft an optimal data architecture, tailor models, & bring your most ambitious AI projects to life.
- Scope with simple internal pilot journey instantly in just 1-day.
- Easily Scale-to-Production, & achieve seamless integration with your existing financial systems.
- Holistic end-to-end support, insights & performance evaluation for successful journey.